Pulse Brain · Growing Health Evidence Index
Tier 3 — Observational / field trialPeer-reviewedOrganic

Comparative efficiency of organic, mineral and organomineral fertilizer on soil properties and crops

Research on Crops · 2021

Read source ↗ All evidence

Summary

This 37-year field experiment (1984–2020) evaluated the agro-ecological efficiency of three fertiliser systems—organic (manure only), mineral (NPK), and organo-mineral (NPK plus manure)—in a crop rotation dominated by grain crops and perennial grasses. Organo-mineral systems, particularly at higher nutrient doses with manure amendment, sustained the highest productivity during both the active treatment period and the seven-year after-effect period (2.96 t/ha grain units, 70% above control). Organo-mineral approaches optimised soil organic matter dynamics and biological activity whilst improving grain protein content, whereas purely organic systems increased starch content and reduced tuber nitrates.

Regional applicability

The findings may have relevance to UK mixed farming systems combining cereals and grassland, particularly regarding optimisation of organo-mineral strategies and soil health outcomes. However, the study's specific location, soil type, and climate conditions are not stated, limiting direct extrapolation to UK conditions without further contextualisation.

Key measures

Crop rotation productivity (t/ha grain units); grain protein content (%); potato starch content and nitrate levels; soil humus status; soil biological activity; cellulose-decomposing capacity

Outcomes reported

The study measured crop rotation productivity (grain equivalent units per hectare), crop quality parameters (protein and starch content, nitrate accumulation), and soil health indicators including humus status, dehumification rates, and biological activity. Comparisons were made across 30 years of active fertiliser application (1984–2013) plus a 7-year after-effect monitoring period (2014–2020).

Theme
Farming systems, soils & land use
Subject
Soil fertility & nutrient management
Study type
Research
Study design
Field trial
Source type
Peer-reviewed study
Status
Published
System type
Mixed farming
DOI
10.31830/2348-7542.2021.139
Catalogue ID
NRmob79t6f-007

Topic tags

Pulse AI · ask about this record

Dig deeper with Pulse AI.

Pulse AI has read the whole catalogue. Ask about this record, its theme, or how the findings apply to UK farming and policy — every answer cites the underlying studies.