Pulse Brain · Growing Health Evidence Index
Tier 1 — Meta-analysis / systematic reviewPeer-reviewedConventional

The biodiversity and ecosystem service contributions and trade-offs of forest restoration approaches

Fangyuan Hua, L. A. Bruijnzeel, Paula Meli, Philip A. Martin, Jun Zhang, Shinichi Nakagawa, Xinran Miao, Weiyi Wang, Christopher McEvoy, Jorge L. Peña‐Arancibia, Pedro H. S. Brancalion, Pete Smith, David P. Edwards, Andrew Balmford

Science · 2022

Read source ↗ All evidence

Summary

This global meta-analysis of 25,950 data pairs from 264 studies across 53 countries quantifies ecosystem service and biodiversity delivery across forest restoration approaches. Native forests substantially outperformed tree plantations in aboveground carbon storage, water provisioning, soil erosion control, and biodiversity conservation, with monoculture and younger plantations in drier regions showing particularly poor performance. Plantations offered a competitive advantage only in wood production, revealing critical trade-offs that forest restoration policy must balance when reconciling environmental and production objectives.

Regional applicability

The findings have relevance to UK woodland restoration and afforestation policy, particularly regarding species composition choices. However, the study's geographic scope (53 countries with substantial representation from tropical and subtropical regions) means that climate-specific findings for drier regions may require contextualisation for the UK's temperate maritime climate, where water stress is less prevalent.

Key measures

Aboveground carbon storage, water provisioning, soil erosion control, wood production, biodiversity metrics across native forests, monoculture plantations, and compositionally complex plantations; stratified by plantation age, climate zone, and restoration approach

Outcomes reported

The study synthesised 25,950 matched data pairs from 264 studies across 53 countries to compare ecosystem service delivery (aboveground carbon storage, water provisioning, soil erosion control, wood production) and biodiversity outcomes across different forest restoration approaches including native forests and various tree plantation types.

Theme
Climate & resilience
Subject
Climate & greenhouse gas mitigation
Study type
Meta-analysis
Study design
Meta-analysis
Source type
Peer-reviewed study
Status
Published
Geography
Global
System type
Agroforestry
DOI
10.1126/science.abl4649
Catalogue ID
BFmommpfum-0wslg7

Topic tags

Pulse AI · ask about this record

Dig deeper with Pulse AI.

Ask about this record, its theme or its relevance to UK farming and policy. Pulse AI uses selected catalogue evidence and cites the sources it draws on.