Pulse Brain · Growing Health Evidence Index
Tier 4 — Narrative / commentaryPeer-reviewedConventional

Reservations Regarding the Soil Quality Concept

R.E. Sojka, Dan R. Upchurch

Soil Science Society of America Journal · 1999

Read source ↗ All evidence

Summary

This paper presents a critical examination of the emerging 'soil quality' concept in soil science, arguing against its premature institutionalisation as a defined scientific parameter. The authors contend that soil quality definitions remain elusive and value-laden, reflecting narrow crop production and ecological perspectives whilst failing to operationally integrate soil's diverse and often conflicting functions. They advocate for a return to value-neutral soil science focused on quality soil management practices rather than subjective societal perceptions of soil quality.

Regional applicability

The critique applies directly to United Kingdom soil science and policy contexts, where similar debates about soil quality frameworks and statutory soil health monitoring have emerged. The authors' caution against premature paradigm adoption without full scientific validation is relevant to current UK policy development around soil health metrics and environmental stewardship schemes.

Key measures

Conceptual and methodological critique of soil quality definition, assessment frameworks, and paradigm shift implications

Outcomes reported

Critical examination of the conceptual appropriateness and scientific validity of institutionalizing 'soil quality' as a defined parameter in soil science. The authors identify concerns about premature paradigm adoption, definitional ambiguity, policy bias, and failure to operationally integrate multiple soil functions.

Theme
Measurement & metrics
Subject
Soil health assessment & monitoring
Study type
Narrative Review
Study design
Narrative review
Source type
Peer-reviewed study
Status
Published
Geography
United States
System type
Other
DOI
10.2136/sssaj1999.6351039x
Catalogue ID
SNmvg7b6v4-gvt5lx

Topic tags

Pulse AI · ask about this record

Dig deeper with Pulse AI.

Ask about this record, its theme or its relevance to UK farming and policy. Pulse AI uses selected catalogue evidence and cites the sources it draws on.