Pulse Brain · Growing Health Evidence Index
Tier 1 — Meta-analysis / systematic reviewPeer-reviewedRegenerative

When does no-till yield more? A global meta-analysis

Cameron Mark Pittelkow, Bruce A. Linquist, Mark Lundy, Xinqiang Liang, Kees Jan van Groenigen, Juhwan Lee, Natasja C. van Gestel, Johan Six, Rodney T. Venterea, Chris van Kessel

Field Crops Research · 2015

Read source ↗ All evidence

Summary

This comprehensive global meta-analysis of 6005 paired observations from 678 studies examined how no-till agriculture performs relative to conventional tillage across diverse crops and environments. Key findings show that yield responses to no-till are highly crop- and context-dependent: whilst oilseeds, cotton, and legumes maintained yields, cereals experienced yield penalties (wheat −2.6%, maize and rice −7.6% to −7.5%), with performance improving substantially after 3–10 years of adoption. No-till performed best under rainfed conditions in dry climates and when nitrogen fertiliser was applied, suggesting that targeting and system adaptations are essential for optimising no-till viability alongside soil conservation goals.

Regional applicability

The United Kingdom, predominantly in temperate humid climates with intensive cereal and mixed farming systems, would likely experience the negative yield impacts noted for maize and wheat in humid conditions during initial adoption phases. The findings suggest UK farmers would need careful management (particularly nitrogen strategies and residue handling) and extended transition periods (3–10 years) to realise yield parity, with particular attention required for rainfed systems on lighter soils. Applicability is strongest for UK cereal-based arable systems.

Key measures

Relative yield (no-till vs. conventional tillage), crop-specific yield changes (%), time since no-till adoption, nitrogen fertiliser application rates, aridity index, climate classification (rainfed vs. irrigated)

Outcomes reported

The study quantified relative yield performance of no-till versus conventional tillage across 678 studies covering 50 crops and 63 countries, identifying key factors influencing yield responses including crop category, aridity index, residue management, no-till duration, and nitrogen rate.

Theme
Farming systems, soils & land use
Subject
Arable cropping systems
Study type
Meta-analysis
Study design
Meta-analysis
Source type
Peer-reviewed study
Status
Published
Geography
Global
System type
Arable cereals
DOI
10.1016/j.fcr.2015.07.020
Catalogue ID
SNmvg7c42z-wvxkas

Topic tags

Pulse AI · ask about this record

Dig deeper with Pulse AI.

Ask about this record, its theme or its relevance to UK farming and policy. Pulse AI uses selected catalogue evidence and cites the sources it draws on.