Pulse Brain · Growing Health Evidence Index
Tier 4 — Narrative / commentaryPeer-reviewedRegenerative

Agriculture and nature: Trouble and strife?

Frédéric Baudron, K.E. Giller

Biological Conservation · 2014

Read source ↗ All evidence

Summary

This review examines the apparent conflict between rising global agricultural demand and the imperative to conserve biodiversity in production landscapes, particularly in developing countries where these pressures overlap. Rather than advocating for a single approach, Baudron and Giller argue that both land sparing (intensifying production on limited land to preserve natural habitat) and land sharing (maintaining mixed agricultural–natural mosaics) are viable strategies whose suitability depends on local context. The authors propose that effective solutions require managing spillover effects, maintaining ecosystem resilience, reducing waste, improving food access in developing regions, reshaping consumption in wealthy nations, and supporting markets and policies aligned with these goals.

Regional applicability

Whilst framed globally, the analysis is particularly relevant to United Kingdom agricultural policy, which increasingly balances productivity targets with environmental stewardship mandates (e.g. Environment Act 2021, agricultural transition schemes). The paper's emphasis on landscape structure, ecosystem services, and market mechanisms resonates with UK agri-environment schemes and regenerative farming initiatives, though the specific land availability and biodiversity contexts differ from developing-country production landscapes that are the paper's primary focus.

Key measures

Conceptual frameworks for land use allocation; criteria for model selection; trade-offs between agricultural intensification and biodiversity outcomes; landscape-scale considerations

Outcomes reported

The study examined two competing models (land sparing and land sharing) for reconciling increased agricultural production with biodiversity conservation, and proposed criteria for selecting between them based on local circumstances. The analysis considered landscape structure, ecosystem services, market dynamics, and consumption patterns as integral to resolving agriculture–nature conflicts.

Theme
Farming systems, soils & land use
Subject
Regenerative & agroecological farming
Study type
Narrative Review
Study design
Narrative review
Source type
Peer-reviewed study
Status
Published
Geography
Global
System type
Mixed farming
DOI
10.1016/j.biocon.2013.12.009
Catalogue ID
SNmvg7d1rw-kx58b6

Topic tags

Pulse AI · ask about this record

Dig deeper with Pulse AI.

Ask about this record, its theme or its relevance to UK farming and policy. Pulse AI uses selected catalogue evidence and cites the sources it draws on.