Home / Dark Matters
A talk by Rob Ward, co-founder of Vitagri

Dark Matters

The hidden workforce that decides what's in our food.

Teaser · 1 minute · narrated
Full length Dark Matters video below
The idea

Every product you grow, make or sell started with a workforce you've never seen.

There are billions of microbes in a teaspoon of healthy soil, and most have never been grown in a lab. Scientists call them dark matter. We're only starting to learn what they do.

Underground isn't a mine. It's a market.

Plants pour sugar out of their roots. Microbes feed on it and pay back with plant nutrition. Root fungi reach soil the root can't, and carry phosphorus and zinc back to it.

We can break the deal.

Bare soil over winter means no living roots, so no sugar. Give a plant more soluble phosphorus than it needs and it feeds its fungi less, and wheat grown that way carries less zinc in the grain. Some sprays hit the helpers as well as the target.

It shows on the plate.

Swap grass for a diet mostly of grain and a cow's gut microbes change. The milk carries less omega-3, less CLA, and less vitamin E and beta-carotene. The cow didn't change. The farm did.

Knowing what is only the start.

Correlation is not causation. Carefully designed farm trials and nutrition analysis estimate the likely effect of a practice on the food, and say plainly when the evidence isn't there yet.

Not every difference favours the system you'd expect. Organic milk tends to be lower in iodine, for example. We grade the evidence; we don't pick sides.

Watch · 20 minutes

Dark Matters: the full film

How soil and rumen microbes shape what's in our food, how farming changes them, and how we find out what really causes what.

Written and presented by Rob Ward, CEO © Vitagri Org Ltd
Read the transcript

The workforce you’ve never seen 0:00

Every product you grow, make or sell started with a workforce you’ve never seen. There are billions of microbes in a teaspoon of healthy soil, and most of them have never been grown in a lab. Scientists call them dark matter. We know they’re there … and we’re only starting to learn what they do. In the next twenty minutes: how a plant buys its nutrition, why a cow can’t digest grass, what happens when we break that deal, and which nutrients in your products farming really changes.

Hi, I’m Rob Ward, a soft-fruit farmer and agri-tech entrepreneur. I co-founded Vitagri with David Rose. With more than sixty people, we work out which farming choices really change the nutrients in the food you grow, make and buy. So, here’s a question to keep in your head. For each of these five foods, how much can the way it’s farmed change one nutrient? Make a guess for each. Hold your guesses. We’ll come back to them.

Part 1: The deal 1:32

A plant makes sugar from sunlight. Then it does something that looks wasteful: it pours some of that sugar out of its roots, into the soil. It isn’t waste. It’s a payment, and a message. Of all the carbon a crop sends below ground, about a third leaves the roots and goes into the soil itself. And the thin zone of soil around a root is one of the busiest places on Earth.

The microbes there wake up and feed on that sugar, and they pay back with plant nutrition. Root fungi grow threads far finer than a root hair. They reach soil the root can’t, and carry phosphorus and zinc back to it — across many crops, plants with these fungi take up more zinc. Bacteria unlock phosphate that’s stuck in the soil. And on clover and beans, other bacteria turn nitrogen from the air into plant food.

Roots pay in sugar. Microbes pay in nutrients. Underground isn’t a mine. It’s a market. And the microbes don’t only deliver. They guard. Scientists have watched it happen. When a leaf is attacked, the plant releases an acid from its roots — a call for help.

A soil bacterium answers, settles on the root, and builds a protective film over it. And a plant under attack can gather a whole protective team in the soil around it. Farmers have seen it at field scale, too. In wheat grown year after year, the disease take-all can fade on its own, as protective bacteria build up in the soil. That’s one example of thousands.

Here’s another. When a plant runs short of potassium, it waterproofs its own roots. It lays down a wax, called suberin, to hold on to what it has — and the same seal slows the water coming in. So a plant protecting itself ends up drinking less freely. Microbes can undo it. Some bacteria dissolve potassium out of rock minerals.

Root microbes have been shown to calm the plant’s stress signal and thin that wax again. And root fungi bring in water from soil the root can’t reach.

Into the cow: the rumen 4:32

Now follow the grass into a cow. A cow can’t digest grass. It has no enzyme that breaks it down. Its rumen — a fermenting chamber about the size of a dustbin — holds billions of microbes in every millilitre. Fibre-digesting bacteria break the grass down, and the cow lives mostly on what they make.

They edit the fat, too. Fresh grass is rich in omega-3, and rumen bacteria turn part of it into a fat that the cow’s udder converts into CLA. So the grass-fed difference in milk is made … in partnership with microbes. And there’s one vitamin no plant or animal can make at all: vitamin B12. Only microbes make it. Rumen microbes make it from cobalt — cobalt that came from the soil, through the grass. The B12 in a steak or a glass of milk started in a field.

Soil microbes, plant, rumen microbes, animal … us. One chain.

The last link: our own gut 5:49

And the last link is our own gut. Many of the plant compounds in food arrive locked to fibre, and our gut bacteria unlock and change them. From the polyphenols in walnuts and pomegranates, some people’s gut bacteria make compounds called urolithins, and other people’s don’t. What we get from food depends partly on our own microbes.

Some of the bacteria on fruit and vegetables even turn up in our gut. James Kinross wrote an excellent book about the dark matter inside us. This is the other half of the story: the microbes that made our food before it ever reached us. Everything you grow, make or sell started as this trade.

Part 2: The broken deal 6:52

So … what happens when we break the deal? Bare soil over winter means no living roots, so no sugar, so no market. Heavy cultivation shreds the fungal threads. Across Europe, intensive farming has been linked with fewer, simpler soil communities — and with the loss of the keystone microbes that hold root communities together.

Then we spread fertiliser at one rate across the whole field, whatever each part needs. Give a plant more soluble phosphorus than it needs and it stops trading: it feeds its fungi less, and wheat grown that way carries less zinc in the grain. Too much nitrogen builds up nitrate in spinach and salad leaves — there are legal limits for it — and often lowers their vitamin C. And bigger, faster yields can spread the same minerals more thinly through each mouthful.

Spread like that, fertiliser keeps a plant growing fast. It doesn’t give it everything a working soil does. And this isn’t an argument against fertiliser. Yields matter, and targeted feeding can be very precise. The cost comes from blanket spreading. Then there’s the treadmill. Some sprays hit the helpers as well as the target. One fungicide shuts down root fungi so reliably that scientists actually use it to do exactly that, in experiments.

Insecticides kill the ladybirds, beetles and wasps that keep pests down, so the pests that survive, or the next ones to arrive, meet no enemies. And the target fights back: septoria in UK wheat has grown resistant to several groups of fungicide. And each product is approved largely on its own, while a field gets several. When fields were sampled, their soils carried residues of several pesticides at once, and the soil microbes differed with them.

When realistic mixtures were tested on ten soils, the effect on the microbes changed from one soil to the next. Testing one product at a time can’t tell you what the combination does. And fields with a long history of heavy spraying had weaker root partners — partners that hadn’t adapted. Fewer helpers, tougher pests. Each spray makes the next one more necessary. That’s a biology problem — and it’s an input-cost and resilience problem too.

Back to the cow: grain diets 9:47

Back to the cow. Swap grass for a diet mostly of grain, and the microbe city changes. Starch ferments fast, acid builds, and the microbes that digest fibre struggle. Push it too far and that’s acidosis, a common problem in intensive systems. Even the fat editing switches to a different route, making a trans fat that shuts down milk-fat production. Farmers know it as milk fat depression.

And the milk and meat carry the difference: less omega-3, less CLA, less vitamin E and beta-carotene — mostly because grain simply contains far less of them than fresh grass — and an omega-6 to omega-3 ratio several times higher. The cow didn’t change. The farm did.

Part 3: What reaches your products 10:55

Back to your guesses. Zinc in wheat: more than doubled, with zinc on the soil and the leaf. Flavonoids in tomatoes: up almost 80% over ten years of organic growing. Blue pigments in blueberries: up about 60%. Omega-3 in milk: up by half. And carrots? Only about 10%. In carrots, the variety matters far more than the farming. At Vitagri we grade every nutrient we measure, from one, where farming moves it a lot and repeatably — often by half again, sometimes several times over — down to five, where a change would surprise us. Here’s what comes out on top. In milk, beef, chicken and eggs, it’s the fats and the fat-soluble vitamins: omega-3, CLA, vitamin E, beta-carotene, and in eggs, vitamin D — sunlight raised it three to four times in one controlled study. Feed decides iodine and selenium, too.

A cow can’t make vitamin E or beta-carotene. And the natural yellow in a yolk comes from beta-carotene in grass, if the hen gets to eat it. Every bit came from what the animal ate. That’s why butter from cows on grass is yellow. For your categories, that means: in dairy, beef, eggs and chicken, specify the pasture share, the finishing diet or the feed — then test those nutrients. In crops, the variety comes first. After that, farming moves the plant’s own defence compounds: the glucosinolates in brassicas, and the pigments in berries and apples.

Specify the variety; test the compounds behind broccoli’s bite, and the nitrate. It moves the minerals you add, like zinc and selenium in wheat. The soil’s own minerals move less, and less reliably. And not every difference goes the way you’d expect. Organic milk tends to be lower in iodine, because conventional cows get more of it in their feed minerals. We grade the evidence. We don’t pick sides. If you’re wondering whether the fall in vegetable minerals over the decades is just bigger yields: partly, yes.

In the longest-running wheat experiment in the world, zinc and iron in the grain fell when the high-yielding varieties arrived in the 1960s, even where the soil hadn’t changed. Which is exactly why we measure, rather than assume.

The way back 13:48

So — put the partners back, and does the food change? In some cases, clearly yes. Strawberries grown with root fungi and a helpful bacterium, on less fertiliser, had more vitamin C and folate, and more of the red pigments too. And in lettuce, root fungi raised the leaves’ phenolics. Beneficial microbes give the plant a mild, harmless challenge that primes its defences … a bit like a vaccine.

Here’s a question for you, then. Do you measure the nutrition of what you buy or grow today? Routinely … for some lines … or not yet? The good news is that the deal can be restored, and the levers are practical. Keep a living root in the ground over winter — cover crops raise the life in the soil. Disturb the soil less. Feed it. Grow more diverse grass: in a UK study, herbal leys raised the minerals in the forage, and the lambs grew faster.

Get fresh forage into the ration. And put fertiliser where it’s needed, at the rate it’s needed, not as a blanket spread. A small study of paired farms in the United States found that after five to ten years of no-till, cover crops and diverse rotations, the crops carried more of some vitamins, minerals and protective compounds. The authors call it preliminary, and so do I. But it points the right way. And if you’ve made a regenerative sourcing commitment, this is the missing piece: what to measure in the food, to know it’s working.

Part 4: From what to why 15:54

We’ve talked about what farming does to the nutrients in food. To understand why, we have to dig deeper into the dark matter. Farming is complex. Every season is different: the weather, the soil, the variety, and hundreds of decisions along the way. All of them matter. You may have heard the saying: correlation is not causation. So what does it mean? A correlation is a pattern: an action and an outcome that tend to turn up together. But the same outcome can come about in many different ways, and a pattern can’t tell you which one did the work.

Take one farm’s wheat. Across five fields, the zinc in the grain ranged from 21 to 38 milligrams per kilo. Was it the soil? The variety? The fertiliser? The weather that year? Each of them could leave the same pattern. To understand why, we need to find the actual causes, not just the patterns. So how do we do that? With carefully designed farm trials, nutrition analysis in the lab, and a causal map, drawn before any analysis, of everything that could change the result. Then methods, from simple comparisons to machine learning, that test each explanation and set aside the ones that don’t hold. At Vitagri, we’ve built Vitagri Vitals, our causal engine for agriculture and food nutrition.

It brings published evidence, farm and food data and causal maps together, to estimate the likely effect of a farming practice on the nutrients in the food, for farms like yours. And it says plainly when the evidence isn’t there yet. And here’s the really exciting part. As you’ve seen today, it’s often the more sustainable practices, living roots, less disturbance, fresh grass, fertiliser where it’s needed, that change the dark matter for the better. So we’re not only working to grow more nutritious food. It’s more sustainable too. And together, that makes a more resilient food system.

The close: pick one line 18:55

Dark matters. What we can’t see decides what’s in our food, and the way we farm decides whether that dark matter can do its job. Every product you grow or buy has a nutrient profile that was set on a farm. So pick one line. Measure the few nutrients that farming really moves, across your own suppliers, and you’ll know whether your sourcing is buying the difference. That’s what we do at Vitagri. And the evidence behind everything you’ve heard today is free to search in Pulse Brain. Thank you.

Put it to work

Start with one product line

Measure its key nutrients across your own suppliers, and see what the differences are. We can help you do it.

Questions

Dark Matters, in short

What is Dark Matters?

A talk and film by Rob Ward, co-founder of Vitagri, about the hidden workforce that decides what's in our food: how soil and rumen microbes shape the nutrients in food, how farming changes them, and the evidence behind it.

Why are soil microbes called dark matter?

There are billions of microbes in a teaspoon of healthy soil, and most have never been grown in a lab. Scientists call them dark matter. We're only starting to learn what they do.

How do soil microbes affect the nutrients in food?

Plants pour sugar out of their roots. Microbes feed on it and pay back with plant nutrition. Root fungi reach soil the root can't, and carry phosphorus and zinc back to it.

How can farming break that deal?

Bare soil over winter means no living roots, so no sugar. Give a plant more soluble phosphorus than it needs and it feeds its fungi less, and wheat grown that way carries less zinc in the grain. Some sprays hit the helpers as well as the target.

Does what a cow eats change its milk?

Swap grass for a diet mostly of grain and a cow's gut microbes change. The milk carries less omega-3, less CLA, and less vitamin E and beta-carotene.

The sources

What this is based on

The main studies behind each part of the talk. Search any of them, and thousands more, in Pulse Brain.

Under the soil

  • Bais et al. 2006. How roots shape the microbes around them. Annual Review of Plant Biology. Read the study
  • Lehmann et al. 2014. Root fungi and zinc in crops, a meta-analysis. Soil Biology and Biochemistry. Read the study
  • Smith et al. 2011. Root fungi and plant phosphorus. Plant Physiology. Read the study

Breaking the deal

  • Tsiafouli et al. 2015. Intensive farming and soil life across Europe. Global Change Biology. Read the study
  • Banerjee et al. 2019. Intensive farming and the key microbes around roots. The ISME Journal. Read the study
  • Grant et al. 2005. Fertiliser phosphorus and root fungi. Canadian Journal of Plant Science. Read the study
  • Ryan et al. 2008. Phosphorus fertiliser, root fungi and zinc in wheat grain. Journal of the Science of Food and Agriculture. Read the study

On the plate

  • Russell & Rychlik 2001. What changes the microbes in the rumen. Science. Read the study
  • Nagaraja & Titgemeyer 2007. Grain diets and the rumen in cattle. Journal of Dairy Science. Read the study
  • Daley et al. 2010. Grass-fed and grain-fed beef compared. Nutrition Journal. Read the study
  • Średnicka-Tober et al. 2016. Organic and conventional milk compared, a meta-analysis. British Journal of Nutrition. Read the study

The way back

  • Muhammad et al. 2021. Cover crops and soil microbes, a meta-analysis. Geoderma. Read the study
  • Montgomery et al. 2022. Paired regenerative and conventional farms. The authors call the findings preliminary. PeerJ. Read the study