Pulse Brain · Growing Health Evidence Index
Tier 3 — Observational / field trialPeer-reviewedRegenerative

Competitive Ability of Three-Crop Mixtures and Pure Stands of Pea, Oats, and Camelina on Weed Diversity in Organic Farming

Shiromi Samiraja, Chao Xiao, Ilja Koli, Saku Juvonen, Asko Simojoki, Laura Alakukku, Pirjo S. A. Mäkelä

Agronomy · 2026

Read source ↗ All evidence

Summary

This two-year field experiment in southern Finland compared the competitive ability of pure stands versus three-crop mixtures of pea, oats, and camelina in managing weeds under organic farming conditions. Whilst pure oat stands provided the strongest weed suppression, crop mixtures—particularly the 33% equal-density mixture—enhanced weed species diversity and evenness, suggesting that intercropping may enable more ecologically balanced weed management in organic systems. The findings indicate trade-offs between immediate weed control and diversity outcomes that may inform organic farming strategies.

Regional applicability

The study was conducted in southern Finland under boreal climatic conditions with similar soil and photoperiod characteristics to much of the United Kingdom's arable regions. The findings on organic intercropping strategies are directly relevant to UK organic farming practice, though results may require adaptation for UK's more temperate conditions and different predominant weed flora; the three-crop mixture approach offers practical applicability for UK organic systems seeking to balance weed suppression with biodiversity goals.

Key measures

Weed species richness, Shannon-Wiener diversity index (H), evenness, dominance, weed biomass; crop mixture composition (pea:oats:camelina at 50:20:30, 33:33:33, and 50:50:50 seeding densities); sampling conducted at five times per season over two years

Outcomes reported

The study measured weed diversity (Shannon-Wiener index, richness, evenness, dominance) and suppression across pure stands and three-crop mixtures of pea, oats, and camelina at varying seeding densities over two growing seasons. Weed species composition, biomass, and community structure were assessed at five sampling points throughout the growing season.

Theme
Farming systems, soils & land use
Subject
Regenerative & agroecological farming
Study type
Research
Study design
Field trial
Source type
Peer-reviewed study
Status
Published
Geography
Finland
System type
Organic systems
DOI
10.3390/agronomy16121125
Catalogue ID
SNmqbu4wod-oe1mrt

Topic tags

Pulse AI · ask about this record

Dig deeper with Pulse AI.

Ask about this record, its theme or its relevance to UK farming and policy. Pulse AI uses selected catalogue evidence and cites the sources it draws on.