Pulse Brain · Growing Health Evidence Index
Tier 3 — Observational / field trialPeer-reviewedConventional

Soil-less is more? A comparative life cycle assessment case study of agricultural growing methods

Antonio Licastro, Roberta Salomone, Giovanni Mondello, Grazia Calabrò

The International Journal of Life Cycle Assessment · 2025

Read source ↗ All evidence

Summary

This comparative life cycle assessment examines the environmental trade-offs between conventional soil-based and soil-less (substrate or hydroponic) horticultural production systems. The study quantifies impacts across the full product lifecycle, enabling evidence-based comparison of growing methods' sustainability profiles. The findings may inform choice of production systems based on environmental performance rather than yield or quality alone.

Regional applicability

The geography of the study is not specified in available metadata; applicability to United Kingdom horticulture depends on whether the case study reflects UK growing conditions, energy mix, and market practices. If conducted in Mediterranean or other climates, transferability to UK temperate horticulture (glasshouse production, outdoor crops) would require contextual adjustment for energy sources and supply chain logistics.

Key measures

Likely to include global warming potential, cumulative energy demand, water use, waste generation, and other environmental impact categories typical of ISO 14040/44 compliant LCA methodology.

Outcomes reported

The study compares environmental impacts across life cycle stages of soil-based and soil-less (likely hydroponic or substrate-based) growing systems. Specific outcome metrics are inferred to include greenhouse gas emissions, resource use, and other environmental burdens typical of LCA studies.

Theme
Farming systems, soils & land use
Subject
Arable cropping systems
Study type
Research
Study design
Life cycle assessment (LCA)
Source type
Peer-reviewed study
Status
Published
System type
Horticulture
DOI
10.1007/s11367-025-02467-2
Catalogue ID
SNmvt2avq9-zszc5g

Topic tags

Pulse AI · ask about this record

Dig deeper with Pulse AI.

Ask about this record, its theme or its relevance to UK farming and policy. Pulse AI uses selected catalogue evidence and cites the sources it draws on.